Settle the debate.
Credentialed reviewers score every major political debate on one transparent rubric. You see who argued well, separate from who you agreed with.
Evidence, logical rigor, and intellectual honesty are not partisan values. Our rubric rewards them equally, whatever the party. If the scores are uncomfortable, demand better from your representatives.
Accountability in three steps
Every scored debate follows the same process, for every debater.
The debate airs
A formal political debate takes place. PodiumScore logs the participants and opens the review window.
Vetted reviewers score
Credentialed reviewers rate each debater on seven dimensions and justify three of them in writing. Each reviewer discloses their political leaning in confidence.
The metrics go public
Composite, cross-aisle, and neutral scores publish together, with claim accuracy alongside. The public sees who won, why, and according to whom.
Seven dimensions, one standard
Pick a dimension and move the slider. Every score from 1 to 10 has a written anchor, so two reviewers who disagree politically still measure against the same definition.
All seven dimensions carry equal weight. Reviewers write justifications for any three dimensions of their choice, plus an overall verdict. Their choices become data too: they show what stood out in each debate.
Score one exchange
Read a 40-second exchange from a mock debate. Score Sen. Voss on Responsiveness, then see how a reviewer panel scored the same answer and why.
Senator Voss, Senator Hale says your infrastructure plan adds $400 billion to the deficit. Is he right? And if not, how do you pay for it?
Look, our roads and bridges are failing. In my state, one in five bridges is rated structurally deficient. Senator Hale voted against the last highway bill, so I don’t think he’s in a position to lecture anyone about fiscal responsibility.Pivot Part of the cost comes from closing tax loopholes for companies that move jobs overseas,Partial answer and the rest pays for itself through growth.No specifics The real question is what it costs us to do nothing.Reframe
Responsiveness
Did Sen. Voss engage directly with the question, or deflect and pivot?
A fictional exchange and a sample panel, shown for illustration. After our first calibration session, this exercise will use a real debate clip and real panel scores.
Same reviewers. Different lenses.
Each dot is one reviewer, placed by their confidential political leaning. Switch the lens to see how the score changes depending on whose judgment you trust.
Reviewer scores for Sen. Voss
View as a table
| Reviewer | Leaning | Score | Counts toward selection |
|---|
Sample data for two fictional senators, shown for illustration. This demo uses a plain average of the highlighted reviewers. The published Cross-Aisle Credibility Score weights each reviewer by political distance using a proprietary method, with outlier controls and a minimum reviewer count.
What reviewers ask us
Short answers to the questions we hear most from prospective founding reviewers.
Founding reviewers come from political science, rhetoric and communication, journalism, law, policy, and competitive debate. We select for analytical rigor, professional credibility, and a demonstrated willingness to score arguments on their merits.
No. Your leaning is used only in aggregate to calculate the cross-aisle and neutral metrics. It never appears next to your name or your reviews, and we treat it with the same confidentiality as peer review.
Every debater is scored on the same seven dimensions with the same written anchors and equal weights. The cross-aisle metric shows whether a score holds up among reviewers predisposed to disagree. If one side performs worse, the scores say so. We report asymmetry and do not manufacture balance.
No. Human reviewers set every score. Our Claim Verification Engine classifies factual claims, and editors review its output before anything is published. Reviewers see the AI analysis only after they submit their own scores, so it informs the record without steering judgment.
Founding reviewers help pressure-test the rubric and take part in calibration sessions on historical debates, starting with the 2012 Obama and Romney debates. That work shapes the standards before we score live presidential primary debates in 2027.
The verdict requires a quorum.
We are assembling our founding class: credentialed voices in policy, law, journalism, and political science. The 2027 presidential primaries are our first milestone.
Start your applicationApply for access
This is an application, and the founding class is limited. It takes about five minutes. We review applications on a rolling basis and reply within 14 days.
- Demonstrated analytical rigor in your field
- Professional credibility and a public body of work
- Willingness to score arguments on their merits, regardless of political alignment
- Interest in shaping the platform's standards and methodology
Application received
Thank you. Your application to join PodiumScore's founding reviewer class is under review. You will hear from us within 14 days.